Embodied masterfully by Maggie Holl[i]nbeck, [Tamsen Donner] … was a delight to watch, and her songs were captivating. – Broadway World

Vivienne Cleary as Margaret Reed and Maggie Hollinbeck as Tamsen Donner are particularly effective and memorable as matriarchs of the two lead households. Each brings a sense of integrity and determination to their women of very different circumstance…. Cleary and Hollinbeck each give a sense of their characters’ conflicted inner lives, which momentarily galvanize the production. – Sacramento Bee